30 Aug 2025 10:44:36
This window has seen the following players come in, either new signings or loanees returning and so I will rate them (just for fun of course and I will possibly be totally wrong come the end of the season)
Hato.8/ 10
Essugo.7/ 10
Santos.8/ 10
Estevao.10/ 10
Pedro.9/ 10
Delap.8/ 10
Gittens.6/ 10
Garnacho.6/ 10.
30 Aug 2025 12:40:30
Mine would be as follows.
Santos 8/ 10
Hato 8/ 10
Garnacho 8/ 10 ?
Gittens 8/ 10
Estavao 8/ 10
Pedro7/ 10
Essuego 7/ 10
Delap 6/ 10
I will definitely be wrong come the end of the season.
30 Aug 2025 12:58:50
Would generally agree with your ratings RDP though Garnacho might just turn out to be better than a 6.or I hope do. What list does show is some limitations of who we got in. Plenty of wingers in squad but only one out and out striker in Delap plus no CB or GK upgrades.
But certainly some v exciting additions.
30 Aug 2025 17:10:54
Ok v early days to judge some of our incoming players in terms of ratings - and are we eg considering balue for money or whstcachieved already or potential or all three? -but assuming a bit of all three these would be. mine at this stage:
Delap 7.5
Essuego7.5
Esteaou 9
Garnacho 8
Gittens 7
Hato 7.5
Pedro 9
Santos 8.5.
30 Aug 2025 18:54:43
I will give ratings for players who I have seen for more than a cameo appearance.
Delap 7
Pedro 8
Estavou 8
Santos 8
Gittens 5
Yes, I’m a mean marker but comparatively similar to the rest of you.